Olivia’s Cafe Ending Brunch at Old Key West, Adding Lunch

Reading Time: 5 minutes

If Crab Cake-Eggs Benedict is your Old Key West tradition, you have until October 5. Olivia’s Cafe at Disney’s Old Key West Resort is ending brunch and replacing it with separate breakfast and lunch services starting October 6.

Quick Summary

• Last brunch service is October 5, 2026
• Breakfast and lunch replace it starting October 6
• Breakfast: 7:30 am – 11:00 am
• Lunch: 11:30 am – 2:00 pm
• Dinner is unchanged at 5:00 pm – 9:00 pm
• New breakfast and lunch menus haven’t been released

What’s Changing

For years, Olivia’s Cafe has run brunch from 7:30 am to 2:00 pm and dinner from 5:00 pm to 9:00 pm.

Once brunch ends, that single morning-into-afternoon service splits in two:

• Breakfast: 7:30 am – 11:00 am
• Lunch: 11:30 am – 2:00 pm
• Dinner: 5:00 pm – 9:00 pm (unchanged)

Disney hasn’t released the new breakfast and lunch menus yet.

The 30-Minute Gap Is the Detail to Note

Look at the schedule again. Breakfast ends at 11:00 am and lunch doesn’t start until 11:30 am.

Under the current brunch format, service is continuous from 7:30 am to 2:00 pm. After the change, there’s a half-hour window where the restaurant isn’t serving.

That’s almost certainly a menu changeover break — kitchens need time to switch stations, and a combined brunch menu avoids the problem entirely.

Practically, it means you can no longer wander in at 11:15 am, which is exactly when a lot of guests on a resort day get hungry. Plan around it.

Why Split Brunch Into Two Services?

Disney hasn’t given a reason, so this is reading the change rather than reporting it.

The likely answer is menu specificity. A brunch menu has to work at 7:30 am and at 1:45 pm, which forces compromises in both directions. You end up with breakfast dishes nobody wants at 2pm and burgers nobody wants at 8am, all held on the line simultaneously.

Separate services let the kitchen do each meal properly. A dedicated breakfast menu can lean fully into breakfast, and lunch can lean fully into lunch without carrying eggs benedict all afternoon.

There’s a commercial read too, and it’s worth stating. Brunch menus at Walt Disney World typically price as a single tier. Splitting into breakfast and lunch usually means breakfast prices come down and lunch prices stay where they are — which is better for guests eating early and neutral for guests eating late.

Or it could go the other way. Until Disney publishes the menus, nobody knows whether this is a guest improvement or a repackaging. Judge it in October, not now.

What’s on the Brunch Menu Before It Ends

The current brunch menu covers a lot of ground — shrimp cocktail and conch fritters through to buttermilk chicken and crab cake eggs benedict.

Standouts before it goes away:

• Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken with scrambled eggs, breakfast potatoes and a biscuit, or roasted garlic mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables — $27.00
• Crab Cake-Eggs Benedict with poached eggs, crab cakes and key lime hollandaise — $26.00
• Bacon Jam Cheeseburger with cheddar, crispy onions and house-made ketchup — $26.00
• Tuna Poke Bowl with edamame, wakame and sriracha dressing — $22.00
• Banana Bread French Toast with Bahamian banana-rum syrup — $20.00

Desserts — Olivia’s Bananas Foster, Key Lime Pie, Coconut Milk Cake, Chocolate Torte, or Pineapple Mango Upside-Down Cake — run $10.00–$11.00.

Kids’ create-your-own entrées run $9.25–$11.50 and include a drink and two sides.

Which Ones Are Actually at Risk

Not everything on this menu is disappearing — some dishes will likely survive into one service or the other.

Safe bets for the breakfast menu: Banana Bread French Toast and the Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken breakfast preparation.

Safe bets for lunch: the Bacon Jam Cheeseburger and Tuna Poke Bowl are lunch dishes that happen to be on a brunch menu.

The genuinely at-risk item is Crab Cake-Eggs Benedict. It’s the dish most specific to brunch as a format — too involved for a quick breakfast menu, too breakfast-y for lunch. If anything gets cut, it’s the most likely candidate.

Same logic applies to the Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken’s dual preparation. Offering the same dish with either eggs and potatoes or mashed potatoes and vegetables is a brunch-menu solution to a brunch-menu problem. Split the services and you probably split the dish.

The Dinner Menu Isn’t Changing

Dinner stays as it is, 5:00 pm to 9:00 pm.

Appetizers — crab cakes, shrimp cocktail, conch fritters — $16.00–$17.00

Entrées lean into Florida Keys flavors:

• Slow-cooked Prime Rib with roasted garlic mashed potatoes and broccolini — $39.00
• Mahi Mahi with fingerling potatoes and chardonnay beurre blanc — $34.00
• Grilled Pork Chop with crispy brussels sprouts and seasonal compote — $32.00
• Shrimp and Grits with cheesy grits, creole sauce and andouille sausage — $31.00
• Captain Wahoo’s Catch of the Day — market price

Plant-based diners have a West Indian Tofu and Coconut Curry at $25.00.

Desserts match the brunch menu. Kids’ entrées range $11.50–$13.50.

Why Olivia’s Matters

Worth some context for anyone who hasn’t been.

Olivia’s Cafe is the only table-service restaurant at Old Key West, which makes it the resort’s dining anchor rather than one option among several.

It’s also one of the more genuinely relaxed table-service spots on property. Old Key West is DVC’s original resort — low-rise, spread out, heavily landscaped, with a pace that has more in common with a Florida Keys condo complex than a Disney hotel. Olivia’s matches that.

Key lime everything is not a gimmick here. The Keys theming runs through the menu properly — key lime hollandaise, key lime pie, conch fritters, mahi mahi, Captain Wahoo’s Catch of the Day.

For DVC Members with Old Key West points, this is their home restaurant, and changes to it land differently than a menu tweak at a park restaurant would.

What To Do

If brunch at Olivia’s is part of your routine: book before October 5. Reservations at Old Key West are generally easier to get than at monorail resorts, but the last few weeks of a discontinued service tend to fill.

If you’re visiting after October 6: expect breakfast or lunch, with no published menu to plan from yet. Check back closer to your dates.

Either way, dinner is unaffected.

The Bottom Line

Olivia’s Cafe at Disney’s Old Key West Resort serves its final brunch on October 5, 2026, switching to separate breakfast (7:30–11:00 am) and lunch (11:30 am–2:00 pm) services from October 6.

Dinner hours and menu are unchanged. New breakfast and lunch menus haven’t been released.

If you want Crab Cake-Eggs Benedict or Banana Bread French Toast in their current form, you have until October 5.

---

---

Looking To Book Your Dream Disney Vacation?